City Risk Report
Flagstaff, AZ
Coconino County · Pop. 76,194
County-level composite · does not reflect parcel-specific conditions
Flagstaff buyers should focus on wildfire exposure, defensible space, and carrier appetite before closing.
Editorial review: 2026-06-19 · Data retrieved: Jun 19, 2026 at 00:00 UTC (snapshot of historical values) · For the latest live data, run a lookup on the Snapshot tool.
Overall Risk Score
Top 10% most at-risk nationally
County-level composite · does not reflect parcel-specific conditions
Overall Risk
Top 10% most at-risk nationally
County-level composite · does not reflect parcel-specific conditions
Expected Annual Loss
Above the national median (top 20% most at-risk)
High · county composite
Est. Annual Insurance
$1,950 – $4,940
Directional range
Last Major Event
2022
Tunnel Fire
Insurance Market Context
These scores are county-level composites derived from FEMA National Risk Index. Individual parcels may differ significantly. This is not a property appraisal.
Market Pressure
HIGH
Arizona's admitted-carrier market is contracting. A broker with state-specific experience is strongly recommended.
Admitted Market Share
64%
Carriers exiting at 7.4% YoY in Arizona.
Residual Market
$2,730–$6,916
annual · last-resort
FAIR Plan / Citizens exposure up 89% since 2020.
Premium Strain Index
Insurance is roughly 4.6% of median household income — well above the 2% middle-income affordability benchmark (First Street flags anything above 5% as financially unsustainable).
Premium-to-income ratio. Based on state Department of Insurance filings, average annual premiums in this area range from $1,950 to $4,940. Not an insurance quote. The First Street 12th National Risk Assessment characterizes any ZIP above 5% as financially unsustainable.
Coconino County Hazard Breakdown
Scores below are from the federal National Risk Index at the county level, refined with parcel-level signals where available (FEMA NFHL for flood, USDA WHP for wildfire, USGS PGA for earthquake, NWS for heat).
Data pending
Hurricane
Low riskTop 10% most at-risk nationally
Earthquake
ExtremeAbove the national median (top 36% most at-risk)
Extreme Heat
HighTop 5% most at-risk nationally
Flood
ExtremeTop 5% most at-risk nationally
Wildfire
ExtremeData pending
Severe Storm / Tornado
Low riskLocal Flood Risk Cost Estimator
Flood insurance costs in Flagstaff, AZ
In Flagstaff, AZ, the directional annual NFIP flood insurance premium is approximately $2,176 (range $1,500–$3,500), and the estimated average historical flood claim in Coconino County is $78,312. Typical mapped exposure aligns with Zone A / AE (SFHA) (county flood percentile: 96).
- NFIP premium (mid)
- $2,176/yr
- Monthly escrow slice
- $125–$292/mo
- Avg. paid claim
- $78,312
- Lender may require
- Likely yes (SFHA)
Heat & HVAC Holding-Cost Estimator
Extreme heat carrying costs in Flagstaff, AZ
In Flagstaff, AZ, directional summer utility strain adds roughly $135/yr above a moderate-climate baseline (heat percentile: 64). Over 10 years, modeled hidden heat + HVAC costs land near $9,350 — about $935/yr to budget for cooling and accelerated equipment wear.
- Est. monthly electric
- $183/mo
- Annual heat tax
- $135/yr
- 10-yr hidden cost
- $9,350
Earthquake Insurance ROI Estimator
CEA-style earthquake coverage math in Flagstaff, AZ
In Flagstaff, AZ, directional earthquake coverage runs about $2,790/yr with a $112,500 deductible exposure (earthquake percentile: 90). Over 30 years, modeled premium spend is $83,700 vs. $23,588 illustrative expected loss.
Coverage may pencil — expected regional loss exceeds premium spend over 30 years.
- Est. annual premium
- $2,790/yr
- Deductible
- $112,500
- 30-yr premium vs loss
- $83,700 / $23,588
Wildfire & FAIR Plan Stress Test
Wildfire insurance non-renewal risk in Flagstaff, AZ
In Flagstaff, AZ, admitted-carrier withdrawal could push coverage through state FAIR / residual market at roughly $8,957/yr — about +$5,512/yr vs. a $3,445 baseline (wildfire percentile: 99).
Non-renewal risk: severe
- Baseline premium
- $3,445/yr
- Residual market est.
- $8,957/yr
- Annual uplift
- +$5,512/yr
What each hazard means for you
Expand any card to see the federal source citation and the buyer-specific action items our research team recommends for this hazard profile.
Hurricane Risk
Flagstaff ranks in the 0th national percentile for hurricane exposure in the FEMA National Risk Index.
FEMA · National Risk Index
Earthquake Risk
Flagstaff ranks in the 90th national percentile for earthquake exposure in the FEMA National Risk Index.
FEMA · National Risk Index
Extreme Heat
Flagstaff ranks in the 64th national percentile for heat exposure in the FEMA National Risk Index.
FEMA · National Risk Index
Flood Risk
Flagstaff ranks in the 96th national percentile for flood exposure in the FEMA National Risk Index.
FEMA · National Risk Index
Wildfire Risk
Flagstaff ranks in the 99th national percentile for wildfire exposure in the FEMA National Risk Index.
FEMA · National Risk Index
Severe Storm / Tornado
Flagstaff tornado data is unavailable. Run an address lookup for parcel-specific assessment.
FEMA · National Risk Index
FEMA Flood Zone
Is this specific parcel in a Special Flood Hazard Area?
The free address snapshot queries FEMA NFHL point-in-polygon and returns your exact FEMA Flood Zone (A, AE, X, etc.) in seconds.
Run a free address lookupCarrier Outlook
Arizona's admitted-carrier market is contracting. A broker with state-specific experience is strongly recommended.
Data Sources
Data Sources & Methodology
FEMA— National Risk Index
Retrieved June 19, 2026
Editorial Analysis
Flagstaff, Coconino County has an overall National Risk Index score of 94 and an expected annual loss score of 80, placing it in the extreme national risk band. The dominant local perils are wildfire, flood, earthquake. The city-level scores below are county-level composites; actual parcel risk can differ meaningfully by neighborhood, elevation, and lot characteristics. Flagstaff's wildfire risk scores 99 at the 99th national percentile, placing it in the extreme band. This is among the highest exposure nationally; standard-market underwriting is increasingly selective and residual-market backup plans are worth modeling. Buyers should assess defensible space, roof and vent class, and proximity to brush. Flagstaff's flood risk scores 96 at the 96th national percentile, placing it in the extreme band. This is among the highest exposure nationally; standard-market underwriting is increasingly selective and residual-market backup plans are worth modeling. Buyers should check FEMA flood zone status, elevation certificate, and drainage history. Flagstaff's earthquake risk scores 90 at the 90th national percentile, placing it in the extreme band. This is among the highest exposure nationally; standard-market underwriting is increasingly selective and residual-market backup plans are worth modeling. Buyers should verify seismic retrofit status and whether earthquake coverage is included. The Arizona insurance market is currently under high pressure: admitted carriers write roughly 64% of new business and the residual market has grown roughly 89% since 2020. For higher-risk parcels in Flagstaff, the residual market can run from $2,800 to $6,200 annually. Directional standard-market premiums for the city typically range from $1,950 to $4,940, but parcel-specific factors can move quotes well outside that band. Buyers should use the address-level snapshot tool to pin these citywide averages to the specific property under consideration. A full L2 or L3 report will also surface flood zone status, insurance-market pressure, and action items tied to the exact parcel.
— Open Data Collective
Historical Events
Tunnel Fire
A major reminder that mountain-city markets still face destructive wildfire exposure.
Post-fire flooding
Burn scars increased runoff and flash-flood risk in nearby neighborhoods.
ZIP Code Risk Profile
Representative ZIP Codes
86001
Flagstaff area
86004
Flagstaff area
Risk varies significantly by ZIP code and parcel. Use the address-level report for precise, parcel-specific scores rather than city-wide averages.
NRI Score Components
County-level composite · does not reflect parcel-specific conditions
Flagstaff Climate Risk FAQ
Ready to check your specific address?
Considering buying in Flagstaff?
Two tiers, one funnel: run a free address lookup, then unlock the depth that fits your buying stage. Both options deliver a 12+ page climate brief before you go under contract.
Full Report
Tier L2
Address-level hazard and insurance feasibility snapshot — five hazards, 30-year projections, carrier pressure signals, and a buy / negotiate / walk-away read for pre-offer buyers. PDF delivered within 5 minutes.
- Five-hazard score breakdown: flood, wildfire, hurricane, earthquake, heat
- 30-year federal climate projections for heat, wildfire, and sea level rise
- Insurance premium estimate range based on state DOI filings
- Clear buy / negotiate / walk-away recommendation with plain-language reasoning
- Comparable lower-risk communities within 25 miles (up to 3 when available)
- Plain-English explanations of SFHA, BFE, residual market, and other insurance terms
- Single PDF you can share with your partner, agent, or inspector
Best for: pre-offer sanity check
Delivered: PDF by email within 5 minutes
Federal data: FEMA, USGS, NOAA, USDA, EPA
Delivered by email within 5 minutes of payment.
Pre-Purchase Audit
Tier L3
Under-contract diligence package: parcel flood zone verification, state insurance market analysis, NOAA claim history, and an evidence-backed negotiation brief to assess earnest-money risk. PDF delivered within 24 hours.
- Everything in the $19 Full Report
- Parcel-level FEMA flood zone verification (Zone A/AE/VE/X — point-in-polygon)
- State insurance market analysis: admitted carrier share, exit rate, residual market growth
- Premium Strain Index — insurance cost as % of local median income, with 2% / 5% affordability benchmarks
- 10-year NOAA Storm Events claim history for the ZIP code
- Negotiation leverage brief with specific, evidence-backed seller-concession asks (typically 3–5; fewer when data is limited)
- Total carrying cost estimate: HO-3 baseline + standalone perils + residual market fallback
- Identifies whether the property may become hard to insure before you close
- Gives you specific talking points for price, credits, and contingency negotiation
Best for: under-contract buyers
Delivered: PDF by email within 24 hours
Includes: 7-day no-questions-asked refund
Delivered by email within 24 hours of payment.